Innovation Policy Appraisals Repository (IPAR)

The INNO-Appraisal project was finalised in February 2010. The project final report is presented below:

This is a searchable repository. It contains all the available appraisals on innovation policy measures referred to in the TrendChart Database. These appraisals relate to measures that Member States have evaluated since 2002. You may use the repository to identify and download appraisal reports that match your search criteria.

Below you will find the full list of all appraisals and their associated policy measures. To see the reports for a particular country, click on the link below that country's flag. For more details on the appraisal report, including the report itself, please click on the appraisal title. For a link to the policy measure in Trendchart, please click on the measure title. Please be aware that there might be more than one report for one policy measure.

You can use the multi-criteria search function to search for appraisals according to their specific characteristics. You can also use this search function to find particular appraisals that are linked to specific types of measures.

Should you have any comments or suggestions for amendment to the repository, please contact us at this link.

ATAustria
29
BEBelgium
6
CYCyprus
1
CZCzech Republic
16
DEGermany
32
DKDenmark
6
EEEstonia
5
ESSpain
2
FIFinland
8
FRFrance
3
GRGreece
8
HUHungary
2
IEIreland
2
ITItaly
0
LTLithuania
0
LULuxembourg
0
LVLatvia
0
MTMalta
3
NLNetherlands
7
PLPoland
17
PTPortugal
3
SESweden
8
SISlovenia
4
SKSlovak Republic
4
UKUnited Kingdom
11
Report Title Policy Measures Covered Country
De effectiviteit van de innovatievoucher 2004 en 2005 NL 47 Innovation vouchers (Subsidieregeling Innovatievouchers) Netherlands
De effectiviteit van de innovatievoucher 2004 Netherlands
E i n d e v a l u a t i e B i o P a r t n e r - p r o g r a m m a Netherlands
EVALUATIE VAN DE DURFKAPITAALREGELING NL 23 Venture Capital scheme Netherlands
Evaluation Leading Technological Institutes NL 19 Leading Technological Institutes (Technologische TopInstituten) Netherlands
Evaluation WBSO 2001-2005, Effects, target group outreach, and execution Netherlands
WBSO nader beschouwd Onderzoek naar de effectiviteit van de WBSO Netherlands
Suomalaisen ilmastoliiketoimintaklusterin synty Climtech- ja ClimBus-ohjelmien arviointi Finland
IMPACTS OF NECK INJURIES RESEARCH AT CHALMERS UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY SE 121 Vehicle and traffic safety Sweden
IMPACT OF GOVERNMENT SUPPORT TO AUTOMOTIVE RESEARCH SE 121 Vehicle and traffic safety Sweden
EFFECTS OF SWEDISH TRAFFIC SAFETY RESEARCH 1971 - 2004 SE 121 Vehicle and traffic safety Sweden
first evaluation of the berzelii centra programme and its centres exselent ucfb uppsala berzelii sbi berzelii SE 82 Berzelius Centres Sweden
FIRST EVALUATION OF THE VINNOVA VINN EXCELLENCE CENTRES NGIL, HELIX, SAMOT AND ECO2 TOGETHER WITH THE STEM COMPETENCE CENTRE CICERO SE 79 VINN Excellence Centre Sweden
uppföljning av vinn nu-företag SE 64 VINN NU Sweden
Generalist and Specialist Evaluation of process and knowledge development 2004 - 2007 Sweden
The results from the Evaluation of VINNOVA’s VINNVÄXT programme Sweden
Innovaatioita julkiseen terveydenhuoltoon FinnWell-ohjelman ensimmäinen väliarviointi FI 84 FinnWell - Healthcare programme 2004 – 2009 Finland
Russia in FLUX Research Programme 2004-2007 FI 60 Russia in Flux 2004-2007 Finland
Impact Evaluation of Finnish Programmes for Centres of Excellence in Research 2000-2005 and 2002-2007 Finland
Research Programme on Social Capital and Networks of Trust 2004-2007 Finland
Yhteiskunnallista vuoropuhelua ja vaikuttavuutta edistämässä ProACT – tutkimusohjelman loppuarviointi Finland
Yhteistyöllä tietoa ja verkostoja Innovaatiorahoittajien yhteisohjelmien arviointi Finland
Teknologiaohjelmat ja innovaatioiden kehittäminen muuttuvassa markkinaympäristössä Finland
Interim Evaluation of the Operational Programme for Economic Activities (POE)- 2000-2006 PT 23 Mobilising Projects for Technological Development (POE) Portugal
Interim Evaluation of the PRIME Programme "Incentives Programme for the Modernisation of Economic Activities" Portugal
Interim Evaluation of the Operational Programme Competitiveness 2000-2006, Greece Greece
Interim Evaluation of the Operational Programme for the Information Society, 2000-2006, Greece Greece
Ex post evaluation of the "Programme for the exploitation of research results through the establishment of academic spin offs" - PRAXE GR 39 Programme for the exploitation of research results through the establishment of academic spin offs PRAXE Greece
Evaluierung des Seed Financing Programms AT 3 JITU Austria
Zwischenevaluierung der aws-Technologieprogramme Austria
Evaluierung von i2 - Endbericht AT 4 i2 - Business Angel Network Austria
Impact Analysis of the School Competition Youth Innovatives (Wirkungsanalyse des Schulwettbewerbes Jugend Innovativ) AT 162 Youth Innovatives - best ideas contest for students Austria
Evaluierung der Fördermaßnahmen 'Impulsprojekte – ForscherInnen für die Wirtschaft' Austria
Ein Evaluierungskonzept für das Kompetenzzentrenprogramm Kplus - Zielkataloge, Kriteriensätze, Abläufe, Materialien Austria
Assessment of competence centre programmes and their future
Evaluierung von TecNet - Netzwerk für Markt- und Technologieinformationen der Innovationsagentur AT 25 tecnet Austria
Die Implementierung von Evaluierungssystemen in FTE Programmen - Konzeptionelle und operationale Überlegungen an Hand des österreichischen Spin-off Programmes AplusB Austria
Zwischenevaluierung der RIF 2000 Regionale Impulsförderung Austria
Schluss-Evaluierung RIF2000 Regionale Impulsförderung Austria
Interimsevaluierung von protec 2002+ Das Programm zur Förderung des Technologietransfer Austria
FIT-IT Interimsevaluierung Austria
Evaluierung des Impulsprogramms ‚Nachhaltig Wirtschaften‘ AT 58 Sustainable Development - Nachhaltig Wirtschaften Austria
Zwischenbilanz 2004 - Impulsprogramm Nachhaltig Wirtschaften AT 58 Sustainable Development - Nachhaltig Wirtschaften Austria
Austrian Genome Research Programme GEN-AU: Mid Term Programme Management Evaluation AT 59 Austrian Genome Research Programme GEN-AU Austria
Zwischenevaluierung des Impulsprogramm FHplus Austria
FHplus Assessment (Executive Summary)
Gutachten STRAPAMO Strategische F&T Partnerschaften mit Mittel- und Osteuropa AT 63 Technology Initiative II - Internationalisation East Austria
Konzept für die Entwicklung von Maßnahmen des bmwa in fForte AT 64 FForte Austria
Interim evaluation of the Austrian NANO initiative AT 67 Nano- und Mikrotechnologie Netzwerkbildung/Nanotechnology and Microtechnology Networks Austria
Evaluierung des Technologietransfer-Programms AT 68 TechnoKontakte Austria
Endbericht der Zwischenevaluierung des Förderprogramms prokis04 Austria
Zwischenevaluierung uni:invent - Bericht im Rahmen der begleitenden Programmevaluierung AT 124 uni:invent Austria
Geistige Eigentumsrechte an Hochschulen: Evaluierung des Programms Uni:Invent 2004-2006 AT 124 uni:invent Austria
Evaluierung der Christian Doppler Forschungsgesellschaft AT 135 Christian Doppler Research Association (CDG) Austria
Evaluierung der Sonderaktion Holzforschung Austria
Zwischenevaluierung Mikrotechnik Österreich Austria
Evaluation FFF - Impact Analysis Austria
Ex-post Evaluierung der Sonderförderungsaktion "Lebensmittelinitiative Österreich" Austria
Begleitende Evaluierung der Kampagne innovatives-oesterreich.at Austria
Study and Evaluation of the Behavioural Additionality of R&D Subsidies Belgium
Evaluation of research and innovation aids to enterprises Belgium
Effectiveness of the Flemish Innovation Co-operation Network BE 56 Flanders: Flemish Cooperative Innovation Networks Belgium
Het STWW-, GBOU- en SBO-programma: Effectmeting van projecten met een economische finaliteit Belgium
KMO-innovatiebeleid levert toegevoegde waarde aan Vlaamse bedrijven Belgium
Evaluation of Clustering Experiences in the Walloon Region BE 60 Wallonia - Clusters Belgium
Subsidiëring van kenniscentra voor innovatie
Ex-ante evaluation of the Operational Programme for Sustainable Development and Competitiveness 2007-2013 Cyprus Cyprus
KONCEPCE VYZKUMU A VYVOJE MPO Czech Republic
Zpráva o vyvoji malého a stredního podnikání a jeho podpore v roce 2002 Czech Republic
Podrobny prehled o realizaci podpory malého a stredního podnikání v roce 2003 Czech Republic
Podrobny prehled o realizaci podpory malého a stredního podnikání v roce 2003 Czech Republic
Koncepce rozvoje malého a stredního podnikání na období 2007 – 2013 CZ 7 Support of SME Innovative Activities Programme Czech Republic
VYROCNÍ ZPRÁVA ZA ROK 2004 SROP CZ 40 Support to Entrepreneurship in Regions - Joint Regional OP 2004-2006 Czech Republic
VYROCNÍ ZPRÁVA ZA ROK 2005 SROP CZ 40 Support to Entrepreneurship in Regions - Joint Regional OP 2004-2006 Czech Republic
VYROCNÍ ZPRÁVA ZA ROK 2006 CZ 40 Support to Entrepreneurship in Regions - Joint Regional OP 2004-2006 Czech Republic
„1/05/JROP – EVALUATION OF MID-TERM PROGRESS OF JROP PROGRAMME IMPLEMENTATION“ CZ 40 Support to Entrepreneurship in Regions - Joint Regional OP 2004-2006 Czech Republic
Pouzití financních prostredku na podporu podnikání v jednotlivych resortech Czech Republic
Operacní program Podnikání a inovace Czech Republic
VYROCNÍ ZPRÁVA ZA ROK 2005 - Operacní program prûmysl a podnikání Czech Republic
VYROCNÍ ZPRÁVA ZA ROK 2006 - Operacní program prûmysl a podnikání Czech Republic
VYROCNÍ ZPRÁVA ZA ROK 2006 - Operacní program prûmysl a podnikání Czech Republic
Operational Programme Prague - Adaptability Czech Republic
OPERACNÍ PROGRAM PRAHA - KONKURENCESCHOPNOST 2007 - 2013 Czech Republic
InnoRegio - Results of accompanying research Germany
InnoRegio- Results of accompanying research Germany
INNO WATT Germany
INNO-WATT Germany
EXIST (1998-2005) DE 21 EXIST - Start-ups from Science Germany
EXIST (1998-2005)
InnoNet Germany
InnoNet Germany
PRO INNO II: Modul 1 (Evaluation of PRO INNO) Germany
PRO INNO II: Modul 1 (Evaluation of PRO INNO) Germany
PRO INNO II: Modul 2 (Evaluation of Projects) Germany
PRO INNO II: Modul 2 (Evaluation of Projects) Germany
PRO INNO II: Modul 3 (Monitoring start of program) Germany
PRO INNO II: Modul 3 (Monitoring start of program) Germany
INNOMAN: Innovation management in SMEs in Eastern Germany DE 33 INNOMAN: Innovation management in SMEs in Eastern Germany Germany
Innovation management in Small Enterprises in Eastern Germany Germany
FUTUR - The German Research Dialogue (Evaluation of the second phase) DE 35 FUTUR (Technology Foresight, former: Delphi 1998) Germany
FUTUR - The German Research Dialogue (Evaluation of the second phase) Germany
Applied Research at Universities of Applied Sciences in Co-operation with Business (FH3) DE 42 Applied Research at Universities of Applied Sciences in Co-operation with Business Germany
Applied Research at Universities of Applied Sciences in Co-operation with Business (FH3)
Innovative Regional Growth Poles DE 57 Innovative Regional Growth Poles Germany
Innovative Regional Growth Poles
Research for the Production of tomorrow (Production technologies) Germany
Research for the Production of tomorrow (Production technologies) Germany
Production technology - Impact analysis Germany
Production technology - Impact analysis Germany
Plasma Technology Germany
Evaluation Plasma Technology Germany
Mikrosystems technology Germany
New quantitative approaches to impact analysis – Methodological study using the example of Mikrosystems technology Germany
Bioregio & Bioprofile Germany
Evaluation of "Bioregio & Bioprofile"
NEMO Evaluation 2005 DE 75 NEMO - Management of Innovation Networks for East German SMEs Germany
NEMO Evaluation 2005 Germany
NEMO Evaluation 2007 DE 75 NEMO - Management of Innovation Networks for East German SMEs Germany
NEMO Evaluation 2007 Germany
Benchmarking Incubators Background Report for the Entrepreneurship Index 2004 December DK 4 Technology incubators Denmark
A Public Good - PhD Education in Denmark DK 5 INDUSTRIAL PHD INITIATIVE Denmark
The Industrial PhD - An effective tool for innovation and knowledge sharing DK 5 INDUSTRIAL PHD INITIATIVE Denmark
Evaluation of the Centre Contract/ Innovation Consortium Programme DK 17 Innovation Consortiums Denmark
Mid term evaluation of the Danish regional ICT effort DK 57 Jysk-fynsk IT programme Denmark
Energy Reseach programme DK 59 Energy Research Programme Denmark
EVALUATION OF THE SPINNO PROGRAMME Final Report to Enterprise Estonia Estonia
Impact Evaluation of Spinno Programme in 2001–2006
Evaluation of the design and implementation of Estonian RTDI policy: implications for policy planning EE 18 InnoAwareness Estonia
Estonian Innovation Awareness Programme - Final Report EE 18 InnoAwareness Estonia
Evaluation of the design and implementation of Estonian RTDI policy: implications for policy planning EE 18 InnoAwareness Estonia
Optimising the Design and Delivery of Innovation Policy in Estonia: an Evaluation of Policy Instruments for Intensifying Business Innovation Estonia
SISE 2006 Report Spain
Evaluation Report of Programme to Encourage Technical Research (PROFIT 2000-2003). Information and Communication Technologies Area Spain
Study on the impact of Research Taxes Credit (CIR) FR 109 Research Tax Credit France
Mid term assessment of Regional incubators structures FR 12 Regional incubators structures France
Assessment of the PREDIT 3
Final evaluation of RNRT (National Network in Telecommunications Research) France
Ex-ante evaluation of the Operational Programme for the Information Society 2000-2006-Greece Greece
Ex-ante evaluation of the Operational Programme for Digital Convergence, 2007-2013, Greece Greece
Ex-ante evaluation of the Operational Programme for Competitiveness and Entrepreneurship, 2007-2013, Greece Greece
Ex-ante evaluation of the Operational Programme for Competitiveness 2000-2006, Greece Greece
The impact assessment of the Educational Support of the "Go-online" Programme GR 40 Network yourself Programme (go-online) Greece
A Gazdasági Versenyképesség Operatív Program közbensô értékelése Hungary
KOOPERÁCIÓS KUTATÓ KÖZPONTOK PROGRAM: A VÁLLALKOZÁSOK VERSENYKÉPESSÉGÉRE GYAKOROLT HATÁSOK; Ex-post értékelés eredményei HU 49 Supporting co-operative research and technology-transfer between companies and higher education (KKK) Hungary
Review of the IDA's R&D Capability Grants Scheme Ireland
Mid-term Evaluation of Productive Sector Operational Programme (Part 4: RTDI Priority) Ireland
Qual è l'effetto degli incentivi agli investimenti?Una valutazione della legge 488 (What's the effect of investment incentives? An appraisal of Law 488) IT 16 Investments in the depressed areas of the national territory - Agevolazioni alle attivit? produttive nelle aree depresse del Paese Italy
Indagine sugli incentivi alla ricerca e sviluppo (Survey on R&D incentives) IT 37 Decree for the implementation of the Fund for Technological Innovation (FIT ex art. 14 Law 46/82) - Direttive per la concessione delle agevolazioni del fondo speciale rotativo per l?innovazione tecnologica di cui all?articolo 14 della legge 46/82 Italy
Single Programming Document (SPD) 2004-2006, MALTA Malta
Ex ante evaluation of the Operational Programme I- Cohesion Policy 2007-2013-Investing in Competitiveness for a better quality of life-MALTA Malta
Ex ante evaluation of the Operational Programme II-Cohesion Policy 2007-2013-Empowering People for more jobs and a better quality of life-MALTA Malta
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme - Improvement of the Competitiveness of Enterprises 2004-2006 Poland
Types of projects realized on a basis of 1.3 measure PL 21 Creation of Favourable Conditions for Companies Development Poland
The influence of 2.2.1 measure of Sectoral Operational Programme "Increase of Competitiveness of Enterprises" on the level of innovativeness of Polish enterprises Poland
The influence of 2.2.1 measure of Sectoral Operational Programme PL 22 Support to Product and Technological Competitiveness of Enterprises Poland
Sectoral Operational Programme Human Resources Development 2004-2006 PL 26 Development of personnel of modern economy Poland
Ex-ante evaluation of the Sectoral Operational Programme Human Resources Development 2004-2006
Improving abilities and qualifications of personnel. Investigation of training projects in 2.3 measure scheme a) SPO RZL 2004-2006 PL 26 Development of personnel of modern economy Poland
Improving abilities and qualifications of personnel. Investigation of training projects in 2.3 measure scheme a) SPO RZL 2004-2006 PL 26 Development of personnel of modern economy Poland
Information on economic and social effects, resulted from realization of directed projects between 2002-2004. Poland
Influence analysis of support granted within 3.4 measure of ZPORR on competitiveness growth of microenterprises Poland
Interim evaluation of the Operational Programme for the knowledge Society (2000-2006) PT 21 R&D Activities by Consortia (POSI) (The corresponding POCTI Measure was integrated in IDEIA PT 33) Portugal
Zakljucno porocilo: Evalvacija ukrepov za spodbujanje razvoja grozdov v Sloveniji v obdobju 2001-2003 SI 6 Industrial Clusters Development Programme Slovenia
Evalvacija izvajanja programa vavcarskega svetovanja v obdobju oktober 2004 - avgust 2005 SI 10 Voucher system for consultancy and training services Slovenia
Entrepreneurship for Youth SI 21 Entrepreneurship for Youth Slovenia
Zakljucno porocilo »Evalvacija razpisov podrocja za spodbujanje podjetništva in konkurencnosti v letih 2001 – 2003« Slovenia
SPRÁVA O VYHODNOTENÍ VYZVY NA PREDKLADANIE PROJEKTOV V RÁMCI SEKTOROVÉHO OPERACNÉHO PROGRAMU PRIEMYSEL A SLUZBY SK 2 The Support for Purchase of Innovative Technologies and Creation of Quality Management Systems Scheme Slovakia
SPRÁVA O VYHODNOTENÍ VYZVY NA PREDKLADANIE PROJEKTOV V RÁMCI SEKTOROVÉHO OPERACNÉHO PROGRAMU PRIEMYSEL A SLUZBY Slovakia
NÁRODNÁ AGENTÚRA PRE ROZVOJ MALÉHO A STREDNÉHO PODNIKANIA - Sekcia štrukturálnych fondov, S P R Á V A O VYHODNOTENÍ VYZVY DE MINIMIS SK 9 Assistance to SMEs Scheme (ASMES) Slovakia
NÁRODNÁ AGENTÚRA PRE ROZVOJ MALÉHO A STREDNÉHO PODNIKANIA - sekcia štrukturálnych fondov, S P R Á V A O VYHODNOTENÍ VYZVY Slovakia
Evaluation of Smart (including SPUR) 2001 UK 9 Grant for Research and Development (formerly SMART) United Kingdom
Evaluation on the Skills Impact of the Smart Scheme UK 9 Grant for Research and Development (formerly SMART) United Kingdom
Evaluation of Teaching Company Scheme (September 2002) United Kingdom
New Learners, New Learning: A Strategic Evaluation of Ufi (2002) United Kingdom
Tracking Learning Outcomes: Evaluation of the Impact of Ufi (2004) United Kingdom
An Evaluation of the UfI/learndirect Telephone Guidance Trial (2007)
Higher Education Innovation Fund Summary evaluation of the first round (2001-05), February 2006 UK 38 Higher Education Innovation Fund (HEIF) United Kingdom
Higher Education Innovation Fund impact survey (Study C), February 2007 UK 38 Higher Education Innovation Fund (HEIF) United Kingdom
Evaluation of the Engineering Technicians Programme UK 40 Engineering Technicians Initiative United Kingdom
Regional Innovation Fund Interim Evaluation UK 44 Regional Innovation Fund United Kingdom
Report of the Independent Review Panel September 2003 UK 55 New Foresight LINK Awards United Kingdom
Economic Impact Study of Business Link Local Service UK 71 Business Link United Kingdom